Real Answers from Real Pilots

Getting a Job / Medical with a Misdemeanor on my record

(joseph) #1

This is my first post on this forum, and I’m sure something like this has been asked on here before; but every case is different so I would like to give as much context to my specific issue as possible. I’ve been digging through multiple forums like JetCareers and Airline Pilot Central and the general concensus is that I am probably OK as long as I have a clean slate from now on.

I will attempt to make this as brief as I can… I am a 22 year old Senior at Ole Miss and although I have been in love with aviation since I was a kid (my dad flies for Delta), I didn’t think it is what I wanted to do until recently. My parents bought an airplane for me to build time and get ratings. So after 6 hours, my instructor, who also instructed my father, thought that I was about ready to solo and suggested I go get a medical.

So on Tuesday I went for my first medical (class 3), and as we all know, the FAA asks for anything you’ve ever been convicted of… so about 3-4 months prior to my 21st (1.5 years ago), I got caught up in a kind of bizarre circumstance due to an error in judgement and a lack of maturity, and got popped with a minor in possession of alcohol charge. It’s a misdemeanor, I wasn’t arrested, and I was NOT in a vehicle. I was standing still in a concert with an empty cup (which are the same cups used for every beverage - alc. and non-alc), was approached by an ABC agent who snatched the cup out of my hand, smelled it, and wrote me a citation. The agent never had any evidence other than anecdotal that it actually was alcohol, which he claimed was something different that what I had. I hired a lawyer to fight it, and when the lawyer read the report, he said that the ABC agent had written the report in a way that the judge would never consider ruling in our favor. In the end, I was a college kid in a college town, so I was guilty no matter what. I heeded his suggestion and I decided to plead guilty and pay the fine in order to be eligible for expungement. I work part time and paid the citation out of my pocket.

So in reference to the medical application form, I didn’t try to hide it, even though it will be sealed/expunged (as the FAA changed the regs on expungement), I disclosed it on the form. The AME said the FAA might cause me issues later and could defer my exam to OKC; but he granted me the medical and I have the paper in my pocket.

To my knowledge, I don’t have any speeding tickets (I could be wrong) or anything else on my record… I am going to do a background check today at the Sheriff’s Dept.

It is my intention to eventually operate part 121, and I’m seeking to inquire how much resistance I will probably encounter attempting to get a SIDA badge, entrance to Canada, getting a 2nd / 1st class medical, and realistically an interview.

Is it likely they will overturn my 3rd class medical?

Is it possible they will force me to go through HIMS or some psychiatric eval because of hypothetical “substance abuse” even though it was a single charge and occurred when i was 20?

Does an MIP appear the same as having DUI?

It will be at least another year, possibly more, before I begin to get my CPL or a 2nd class medical - so i’m hoping that putting time between me and my transgression with help me. It is solely my responsibility that it happened, and at the time I didn’t want to do anything aviation related. The field I had intended to go into doesn’t require security clearances and background checks to the extent the field of commercial aviation requires. I feel like I could explain it in an HR interview setting.



I really don’t see this being much of an issue for you, it sounds like a very minor offense that happened at a young age.

What I do see as an issue is your attitude about it. You wrote a very long explanation of how the officer didn’t have proper evidence and how you were wrongly convicted, but let’s cut to the chase, you were drinking underage and knew exactly what you were doing, then you got caught. A much better attitude on your part would be something like “I was young and made a mistake by drinking underage. I learned my lesson and have respected the law since then.”

Also, how do you not know whether or not you have had speeding tickets? You have either been pulled over and ticketed or you haven’t, most people don’t forget such things.

I would not spend any more time applying for third or even second class medicals. The airlines all require a first class medical, so you might as well make sure you are eligible for one now, before you spend more money on flight training.


(Dakota) #3

I have an MIP also. I got my first class medical a couple months ago and the AME said I will probably receive a letter from the FAA in the mail. Sure enough 6-8 weeks later I got a letter from the FAA saying that I have been granted a 1st class medical, but due to my answer on 18.w (I believe that’s the question, off the top of my head, where you disclose that you have an alcohol-related charge) I will now have to check that box every time I apply for a medical and write in “previously listed, no changes”. If you incur another alcohol or drug-related charge, that would be an issue. It will cause them to re-review your medical, possibly suspend/revoke it, and it would show a pattern of alcohol/drug-related charges which would definitely hurt your employment opportunities.

(joseph) #4


I appreciate the response. The citation was a result of an temporary error in judgement and a lack of maturity on my part. That mistake was mine and I own it. I have learned that before making a judgement with anything, including aviation, ask my self, “what am I risking and what am I gaining.” That question has since kept me out of any kind of trouble.

On the speeding ticket question, I was given a citation at 17 years old and did driving school. To my knowledge it was never reported to the insurance nor was it placed on my driving record. I recieve both a “Good Driver” and a “Good Student” discount on my insurance - the requirements for those both have clauses for a clean driving record. I also have been told that at 18 years old, your record clears itself; but I don’t know that to be credible. I will know once I do a background check this afternoon.


(joseph) #5


Thanks for your time and sharing your experience.

Out of curiosity, how long ago was your citation?



On the speeding ticket issue, the airlines and the FAA will simply ask “have you ever…”, not “what does your record show?”. So the answer is, yes, you had a speeding ticket, but it was dismissed, etc. The whole US judicial concept of innocent until proven guilty, juvenile records, purged records and so forth does not apply to the FAA. That being said, I wouldn’t worry about it.


(Dakota) #8


Mine occurred 4 years ago.



I’m with Chris here. Your record (provided you behave) won’t be an issue but as someone who’s participated in pilot hiring your answers most definitely are. You know what? I receive a “Good Driver” discount every 6 mos and I had come within 1 point of losing my license for speeding tickets so that doesn’t prove much. Did it come up during my first airline interview? You BET it did and responded that I was stupid and irresponsible, that’s ownership. If I were conducting the interview and someone spouted some magic words they’d read or were told like “it was a result of a temporary error in judgment and a lack of maturity” I’d probably start laughing and ask so that was the only time you’ve ever had a red solo cup in your hand? You also stated “To my knowledge, I don’t have any speeding tickets” but then said “I was given a citation at 17” so you HAVE MOST DEFINITELY had a speeding ticket, have therefore lied and your interview is over. Yes it’s that simple. This is not a game of semantics, trying to misdirect the blame or saying magic words you think the panel wants to hear. Airlines look for good pilots who’ll fit the company profile, are honest and won’t look to pass blame. I’m thinking you need to work on that maturity thing a little more.

Btw, I have to ask, if Dad’s a pilot at Delta why aren’t you having this conversation with him? Is he not aware of your issues?


(Peter Banning) #10

I blame this on Hugh Freeze.